Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Lokpal Bill row: Team Anna says Congress divide has impacted talks; govt strikes back

New Delhi:  Ahead of a crucial and fourth round of talks with Anna Hazare's representatives, the government has indicated it's running out of patience with the activists. Last night, three of Anna's aides said negotiations were "back to Square One" after they met with Law Minister Salman Khursheed and Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee.

"It seems those who were skeptical about us holding these talks have been proved right," said Mr Khursheed this morning to NDTV. "I'm willing to have talks with them. If they don't want it, why should they blame anyone else?" he asked.

74-year-old Anna is on the tenth day of his hunger strike against corruption. Doctors are worried about his health. The government has prepared an emergency evacuation plan for the activist, but say they will enforce this only upon the advice of Anna's doctors who are checking him every two hours.

Last night, Mr Khursheed said the talks with Prashant Bhushan Arvind Kejriwal and Kiran Bedi were "courteous and civil."   Team Anna did not offer this optimistic spin. They accused the government of retracting promises made in their first set of talks on Wednesday night - at that time, the activists said, the ministers appeared willing to meet them halfway. That cooperative spirit had evaporated by last night, according to Team Anna; its members were critical of the language and tone of the two ministers.

Mr Kejriwal said "We are victims of Congress politics." He said the ministers last night informed him that there's a divide within the Congress over whether to engage with the activists. Mr Kejriwal blamed senior ministers P Chidambaram and Kapil Sibal for suggesting to the government that negotiations with Team Anna are not merited.  Mr Khursheed did not deny this. "My cabinet colleagues did not want me to hold talks. They were probably right. We hold talks and it leads to this," he said with some measure of bitterness.

The government and Anna are battling over whose legislation on a new important bill to tackle corruption should be considered by Parliament. The Lokpal Bill creates a new independent agency (Lokpal) to investigate charges of corruption among public servants.  The government's version has been introduced in Parliament; it is designed to under-achieve, says Team Anna. The activists have drafted their own version which they refer to as the Jan Lokpal Bill or People's Lokpal Bill. Team Anna wants the government to withdraw the Lokpal Bill and put the Jan Lokpal Bill to debate in Parliament. The government says that's not possible because it violates parliamentary processes. So it has offered to send the Jan Lokpal Bill to the same parliamentary committee that's received the government's Lokpal Bill.

At a meeting attended by the leaders of all political parties last evening, the Left and the BJP agreed that the government should bench its version of the bill and introduce a new draft that incorporates features from Anna's version as well as suggestions by other civil rights activists like Aruna Roy. However, different parties also emphasized that while it is critical to reach a truce so that Anna ends his fast, the government should ensure that parliamentary procedure is not subverted. This direction from the Opposition may have emboldened the government to take a firmer stand with Team Anna at last night's meeting.

What Team Anna wants is for their version to be introduced in Parliament within four days; and then put to vote and passed (with amendments, if needed) before this Parliament session concludes on September 8. Mr Khursheed denied that this had earlier been considered by the government. "Did we earlier say we would hand over Parliament to them and later we said no?" he asked. 

Anna's health updates

New Delhi:  As Anna's fast enters the tenth day and concerns over his health mount, here are the latest health updates:

Aug 25 9:30 am: Dr Naresh Trehan, expressing concerns over Anna's health, says, "It is a worrying situation, we are monitoring him closely... examining him every two hours."   

Aug 24 08.58 pm: Dr Naresh Trehan, after examining Anna in the evening said the Gandhian was doing fine. Dr Trehan said Anna's vital stats were alright. This update comes amidst reports that Anna's health was deteriorating.

Dr Naresh Trehan told the crowds at Ramlila Ground, "We have just examined Annaji. His blood test reports have arrived. As compared to yesterday, some figures (in the report) have stabilized, while others have improved. His blood pressure and heart rate is more stable as compared to yesterday.

"However, we have to keep a close eye on his health. I and my team will return later at night to examine him again and then we will decide what do we need to do for his safety. The rest he is taking is working for him and he is healing himself. We will be happy to see his condition stabilize completely," he added.

Aug 24 11:10 am: The 74-year-old anti-corruption crusader has lost another 200 grams in the past 24 hours with his weight settling at 66.2 kg. He was 72 kg before he began his fast on August 16. His blood pressure was recorded at 104/86 while blood sugar was 106 and pulse rate 82.

"After his intake of fluid was increased, his health has stabilized. We have put the team of doctors on full alert. We are keeping a strict vigil on his health," Dr Naresh Trehan told reporters at the Ramlila Ground after examining him.

Aug 24 9:27 am: Dr Naresh Trehan: "We just examined Anna. He slept all right. Condition looks better after rest. In yesterday's blood tests seemed ketones are increasing and parameters deteriorating. We told him he should get admitted in hospital for safety. He refused outright and said I will not move from here. Then he agreed to intravenous to be kept out of danger zone and then said his conscience doesn't permit it. We recommended an increase in his water intake. That might help. And rest. He should not strain himself. We are worried that the catabolic stage has started.

Link resource : http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/live-blog-anna-s-health-updates-128588

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

Anna agrees to 14-day fast at Ramlila Maidan

In a late night breakthrough, Anna Hazare and his team have agreed to 14-day fast at Ramlila Maidan in New Delhi. The social activist, who will go under a check up at Tihar jail at 10 am, will reach the protest venue around 3pm in an open jeep. Though for the time being there has been a breakthrough, Anna Hazare's basic demand of civil society draft of lokpal bill being introduced in Parliament remains.

Police negotiators, Hazare and his associates came to an agreement on several issues. They agreed that the fast venue would be the spacious Ramlila Grounds and that there would be no ceiling on the number of protesters.

They also agreed that loudspeakers would be used at the venue and that Hazare would be examined by government as well as private doctors.

Police allow Anna 7 days protest at Delhi's Ramlila Maidan

The Delhi Police have given Anna Hazare seven days to protest at Ramlila ground. According to media reports, the police is also to extend time period to more than seven days later on.  Earlier on Wednesday, noted lawyer Prashant Bhushan, a member Anna Hazare's anti-coruption campaign team, on Wednesday told the government that Anna will come out of jail only if allowed to fast without conditions.

Anna Hazare and his team were in discussions with government and police over the venue of his fast after he comes out of Tihar Jail. According to latest media reports, government may allow Ramlila Maidan as venue for Anna's protest after he comes out of jail.

Speaking to supporters after meeting Hazare, lawyer Prashant Bhushan told the crowd of supporters outside the jail that the Gandhian would come out only if he is allowed to fast without conditions.
Bhushan said government and police were discussing with Hazare and his aides options of fast venue -- JP Park or Ramlila Maidan -- where he could launch his fight for a strong lokpal.



He said if conditions are imposed, then Hazare will continue with his fast inside the jail. He also told the crowd that people of Delhi have been asked to come to India Gate for a march to Jantar Mantar in support of a strong lokpal and fight against corruption.

Hazare had earlier sought permission from Tihar Jail authorities for a meeting with some of his top associates to plan his strategy.

The meeting was attended by Bhushan, Kiran Bedi, Medha Patkar, Manish Sisodia and Swami Agnivesh. Deputy Commissioner of Police (Crime) Ashok Chand was also present at the meeting.
Hazare also met Sri Sri Ravishankar and yoga guru Ramdev in the prison.

Link Resource : http://www.hindustantimes.com/Police-allow-Anna-7-days-protest-at-Delhi-s-Ramlila-Maidan/Article1-734262.aspx

Anna steadfast on demands, announces India Gate March

There were no signs of a let up between Anna Hazare and the government on Wednesday afternoon with the social activist reiterating that he would not come out of his self-imposed stay in Tihar Jail unless allowed to fast without conditions.

After a meeting with Hazare inside jail, close associate Prashant Bhushan said the government and the police were discussing with them options of a fast venue -- JP Park or Ramlila Maidan -- where he could launch his fight for a strong Lokpal Bill.

Bhushan said if conditions were imposed, Hazare would continue his fast inside the jail.

Even if it was Ramlila Maidan, their fast would not bow to any conditions set by the government, Hazare's other aide Manoj Sisodia said.

The government is not ready to allow a fast for more than five days while Team Anna's relentless demand is permission for a month. 

The Gandhian, who continues his fast inside the jail – though he was released last night – appealed to his followers to assemble at India Gate at 4 pm, from where a rally would be taken out towards Jantar Mantar in support of his Jan Lokpal Bill.

Hazare's aide Prashant Bhushan “invited” all to join the anti-corruption leader's movement and the team at India Gate. 

Hazare also sent out word to his supporters from inside jail, asking them to be calm and to maintain peace.
Till afternoon, while debates raged between the government and the Opposition in Parliament, it was obvious a compromise formula was far from sight, the sticking point now being the length of the fast. 

Link Resource : http://www.indianexpress.com/news/anna-steadfast-on-demands-announces-india-gate-march/833091/
... contd.

More trouble for govt if Anna Hazare moves court

The government will be on the backfoot if Team Anna takes the issue of the activist's detention to court, says Vicky Nanjappa
Home Minister P Chidambaram  on Tuesday made it clear that Anna Hazare and his team could have moved the court if they had problems with the conditions imposed on the activist's proposed fast by the Delhi police.

But given the glaring loopholes in the hasty action taken against Hazare, the government seems to be on a very weak footing. 

Former Karnataka Lokayukta Justice Santosh Hegde, who was a member of the joint drafting committee of the Lokpal Bill, stated that the arbitrary act of detaining Hazare would count against it in a legal arena.

The government may argue that the Delhi police had apprehended trouble from Hazare's protest, but it would have to explain why Hazare was detained hours before he could start his fast.
The Constitution clearly states that no person shall be detained arbitrarily without solid ground being provided for the detention.
It is the government's responsibility to organise adequate security during such protests. As the Delhi government has notified certain areas in the capital to stage protests, the demand by Team Anna to hold protests in these areas is legally valid.
The government doesn't have the right to impose a time-frame for a protest as an individual or a group has the right to protest for as long as he/they want.
The government does have the right to restrict the number of vehicles parked near the area of protest.
According to former advocate general of Karnataka Ashok Harnahalli, the Supreme Court should have acted sooner on the case filed against the crackdown on Baba Ramdev's  protest in Delhi. The court's stance about the yoga guru's case would have set a precedent for such legal matters.
In the absence of a clear-cut judgment in such cases, the government is likely to rely on the various judgments we have on bandhs and strikes. 

A landmark ruling of the Kerala  high court, upheld later in part by the Supreme Court, had termed bandhs as unconstitutional. The verdict stated that bandhs disrupted normal life and hit essential services. 

But this verdict might not be the benchmark for Hazare's case as the activist had not called for a bandh.
Hazare's refusal to leave Tihar jail may land the government in further trouble, as keeping a prisoner in jail despite a release order is an illegal act. Hazare can argue that he refused to leave the prison as he was apprehensive about being arrested again once he started his protest.

Any person who has been detained for more than 24 hours has to be produced before a magistrate. Hazare was remanded to judicial custody and the order of release was issued later. In spite of his refusal to leave Tihar jail, the police should have produced him before the court.

Any verdict by the Supreme Court on such a case will be crucial for such large-scale protests in the future as the country needs legal guidelines about them. While a government cannot refuse a citizen the right to protest, it can subject a protest to reasonable conditions. 

The court will also have to determine if the government's actions were too drastic or if the situation warranted such action.
Link Resource : http://www.in.com/news/current-affairs/fullstory-more-trouble-for-govt-if-anna-hazare-moves-court-20181334-in-1.html

Shehla Masood Shot Dead

Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has struggled for months over how to deal with the popular Hazare and his followers, who have become a serious challenge to the authority of the government. According to the NDTV report, the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) led by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) will meet today to work out a clear strategy to take on the government over Hazare and the Lokpal Bill. VISIT SOURCE Indian Social Activist Anna Hazare Arrested:


“We have detained him as he did not budge from his position of defying prohibitory orders,” police official said. Senior police officials, including DCP (Crime) Ashok Chand, met with Hazare –prior to his arrest – in a bid to convince him to not go ahead with his planned protest defying prohibitory orders. read more APAKISTAN NEWS.COM:
Meanwhile, Times of India reports that an RTI activist and a strong supporter of Anna Hazare’s anti-corruption movement, Shehla Masood was shot dead around 11.30 am on Tuesday. Shehla Masood had led demonstration at activist Anna Hazare’s last call in April.
Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP) Adarsh Katiyar told to the media sources in a statement, “Shehla Masood was shot dead around 11 am when she was sitting in her car”.

Govt says went by the book, ready always to talk to Hazare

New Delhi The government on Tuesday took tough measures against Anna Hazare while simultaneously underscoring that it was never undemocratic in its actions and had tried to be as accommodative as possible.
Union Home Minister P Chidambaram said the pre-emptive police action against Team Anna was resorted to after they refused to comply with restrictions imposed by the Delhi Police.

Along with his two colleagues who are part of the Group of Ministers on media, Information and Broadcasting Minister Ambika Soni and HRD Minister Kapil Sibal, Chidambaram sought to rebuff any impression that the UPA government was trying to muzzle the voice of civil society. His argument was that they had been reasonable in giving Hazare a chance to not only proceed with his programme but also to accommodate his standpoint on the Lokpal Bill. 

There was a distinctive change in the government’s approach towards Hazare, which made no personal attacks against the activist, compared to the discordant note struck by the party a couple of days ago. Congress spokesperson Manish Tewari had then pointed to corruption charges against Hazare.
Senior ministers had informally disapproved of such criticism, with Rahul Gandhi agreeing with the perception that “Anna cannot be equated with Ramdev”. For the second day today, Rahul held discussions with senior UPA ministers, Pranab Mukherjee, P Chidambaram and Kamal Nath, on the Hazare crisis.
“We are with Anna Hazare on the issue of corruption,” Chidambaram said at a press conference. “But nowhere in the world is protest allowed without any conditions. If anyone is not satisfied, they can take legal recourse.”

The government maintained it had tried to reach out to Hazare on Monday but could not do so, and that the three of them had no hesitation engaging with him even now. “The chairperson of the standing committee looking into the Lokpal Bill has invited Team Anna for another round of discussions,” said Chidambaram.
“There is no way we can allow Parliament’s right to frame laws to be taken away,” Chidambaram said. “If laws are not to be made by Parliament but by some social activists in a maidan — however well-meaning they may be — they are beyond my comprehension.” While “right to protest is a Constitutional right”, there were also a constitutional responsibility that the government had to fulfil, Sibal said.

The three ministers suggested that the Team Anna initiative was not entirely a spontaneous one and that they might have political backing from the BJP. “The movement is well thought out,” Soni said. Sibal pointed to media reports that Kiran Bedi was accompanied by two BJP councillors.

Link Resource  : http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/Govt-says-went-by-the-book--ready-always-to-talk-to-Hazare/832905/